Is there a real feature here?
Users were saying their ring data seemed to “predict” an injury or a missed period before they noticed symptoms. I set out to find out whether a responsible product could come from that signal.
Energy availability, for every athlete
The obvious move was a women’s health feature. I framed it around energy availability instead. REDs comes from a long-term mismatch between the energy athletes take in and what training demands, and it affects men too. Published prevalence estimates run from 23–80% in female athletes and 15–70% in male athletes, depending on the sport and method.
Framing it as menstrual health would have left out a large part of the people at risk. This change shaped who the feature is for, which data matters and how it’s described.
What a ring can and can’t know
Before designing anything I read the 2023 IOC consensus statement on REDs. Almost every validated indicator needs lab work, a bone scan or a clinical interview, none of which a wearable has. The ring’s signals (resting heart rate, HRV, sleep and cycle data) all sit in the weakest evidence tier, which the IOC calls “potential indicators” with no validated thresholds.
That ruled out a “REDs detector.” The product instead flags a sustained pattern and hands the user to a validated screening questionnaire and a clinician. Deciding what not to claim was the key product decision.
Where the gap is
| Product | Strength | What’s missing |
|---|---|---|
| Whoop | Strong physiological monitoring; Health Monitor flags deviations | Attributes changes to “stress or illness”; no energy-availability framing |
| Garmin | HRV status, training readiness, acute-to-chronic load ratio | No layer that connects the signals; cycle-aware training only through a partner app |
| Wild.AI, FitrWoman | Connect training and cycle phase | Female-only and cycle-first; daily manual logging hurts retention |
| Opportunity | Highest RHR/HRV accuracy against ECG in a published comparison, plus built-in cycle tracking | Room for an inclusive, pattern-based feature no one offers yet |
Three calls with real precedent
Stay a wellness product
In July 2025 the FDA sent Whoop a warning letter over a blood pressure feature it saw as diagnostic. REDs is a named syndrome, so the app never tells a user they have it. It shows a pattern, offers a screening and points to a clinician, which the FDA’s 2026 wellness guidance allows.
No energy numbers, anywhere
In 2017 Google pulled a Maps feature that converted walks into calories after eating-disorder clinicians raised concerns. The same risk was one design decision away here, so the feature uses pattern language only.
Never share with coaches
The IOC documents coaches pressuring athletes about weight. Results can go to a parent or guardian (for minors) or licensed sports medicine staff. The coach option doesn’t exist at all.
No single-night alerts
Heart rate and HRV shift for many reasons: illness, travel, alcohol, one hard block. Flags need a multi-week trend, and copy calls it “a pattern worth a conversation.”
Low-risk release first
| v1 · Fueling Awareness | v2 · Pattern Detection & Screening | |
|---|---|---|
| Trigger | Training load rising faster than the user’s recent baseline | Multi-week shift in resting heart rate, HRV and sleep, plus cycle changes for users who track them |
| User sees | A dismissible card with general fueling education, reviewed by a sports dietitian | A dismissible card, an optional validated questionnaire, a score to take to a clinician |
| Who gets it | All users with enough training data | A small opt-in beta group only |
| Body data used | None | Physiological trends; no weight or calories |
| Why this order | Builds trust and engagement data with little risk | Higher regulatory and psychological risk; ships only after v1 earns trust |
Both releases share the same rules: no push notifications, a one-tap off switch with no “are you sure?”, and the same copy for every sex, age and sport.
Safety counts as much as engagement
Is it working?
- Beta opt-in rate
- Share of flagged users who complete the questionnaire
- “Did this flag feel fair?” survey score
- Share of screened users who follow up with a clinician
Is it safe?
- How often users turn it off after a flag
- Support contacts about body image, eating or compulsive exercise
- False-positive rate against clinical follow-up
A high turn-off rate or any sign of psychological harm stops a wider rollout, however good the engagement numbers look.
What I’d test next
- How many weeks of change should trigger a flag: 2, 4 or 6? This needs sports science input and tuning during the beta.
- How the logic should work for people on hormonal contraception, where cycle data reads differently.
- Licensing for validated screening tools such as LEAF-Q and LEAM-Q.
- How to recruit the beta without targeting people based on inferred risk, which the design otherwise avoids.
Key sources: Mountjoy et al., 2023 IOC Consensus Statement on REDs, Br J Sports Med; Torstveit et al., prevention of REDs narrative review, Br J Sports Med 2023; FDA General Wellness guidance (revised January 2026); FDA warning letter to Whoop (July 2025).
Self-directed portfolio project. Not affiliated with or commissioned by Oura.