Written for billing staff, sent to families
Denial letters are written to meet regulations and to be read by billing offices. They lead with codes and dollar columns, and they bury the two things a family needs most: whether they owe money and what to do next. I could read these letters because it was my job. Most parents can’t, and with commercial insurance a denial can turn into the family’s bill.
The same denial, two ways
Both letters are fictional. The plan, people, provider, numbers and policy are invented, and real appeal rules vary by plan and state.
Before: a typical notice
NOTICE OF ADVERSE BENEFIT DETERMINATION
| DOS | Service | Billed | Allowed | Plan paid | Reason | Member resp.* |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 03/14/26 | 70553 MRI BRAIN W/O & W/ DYE | $3,240.00 | $0.00 | $0.00 | 50 | $3,240.00 |
Reason code 50: These are non-covered services because this is not deemed a “medical necessity” by the payer.
This determination was made based upon the clinical criteria set forth in the applicable Medical Policy (MP-112) and a review of submitted documentation. The documentation submitted does not support the medical necessity of the service rendered as defined by the member’s Certificate of Coverage.
You or your authorized representative have the right to request an internal appeal within 180 calendar days of receipt of this notice. Upon request and free of charge, you may receive reasonable access to and copies of all documents, records and other information relevant to your claim. If your situation meets the definition of urgent under the law, your review will generally be conducted within 72 hours. Please refer to the enclosed Appeal Rights document for additional information regarding internal and external review procedures.
*Member responsibility may be subject to provider contractual obligations and benefit plan provisions. This is not a bill. Retain for your records. TTY 711.
After: the redesign
We didn’t pay for Jordan’s MRI. Here’s what that means and what you can do.
What happened
On March 14, 2026, Jordan had an MRI of the brain at Example Pediatric Associates. We decided not to pay for it because the records we received didn’t show it was medically necessary under our rules.
Do you owe money?
Not yet. Don’t pay a bill for this MRI right now. If this decision stands after any appeal, you could owe up to $3,240. We’ll write to you before that happens.
What to do next
- Call Jordan’s doctor’s office first. Many denials are fixed when the office sends more records or corrects a billing code. Ask them to appeal for you.
- You can also appeal yourself by September 28, 2026. Use the enclosed form, or call us.
- Is Jordan’s care urgent? Ask for a fast review. We’ll decide within 72 hours.
Why we decided this
Our reviewer used our policy for brain imaging (MP-112). You can ask for a free copy of that policy and the records we looked at.
5 Questions? Call 1-800-555-0100 (TTY 711), Mon–Fri 8–6.
For billing offices: claim 2026-0000000-00 · member XEH000000000 · CPT 70553 · reason code 50 · processed 04/02/2026
What changed and why
Lead with the decision in plain words
The old letter opens with IDs and a table. The new one names the child, the service and the decision in its first two sentences.
Answer “do I owe money?” right away
It’s the first question every family asks. The old letter shows $3,240 under “Member resp.” and then says it “may be subject to provider contractual obligations.” The new one gives a direct answer and the worst case.
Steps in order, with real dates
“Within 180 calendar days of receipt” becomes a date. The doctor’s office comes first because, from my appeals work, many denials came from coding errors or missing records that the provider can fix fastest.
Explain the reason, and offer the evidence
The family’s right to see the policy and records stays in, written as something they can ask for.
Keep the codes, move them down
Billing staff still need claim numbers and reason codes, so they stay at the bottom where they don’t get in the family’s way.
How I’d know it works
- Recruit 6–8 parents who have had an insurance denial, with a range of health literacy levels.
- Show each parent one version, then the other, in alternating order.
- Ask three questions: What was denied? Do you owe money right now? What would you do first?
- Measure correct answers and time to answer, and note where people get stuck or misread.
- Review the wording with billing and appeals staff to check it stays accurate and compliant.
Success: most parents answer all three questions correctly in under a minute with the new letter.